Sipped Right iconSippedRight

Whiskey · Modern Classic · Bittersweet

Little Italy Recipe

A Manhattan gone bittersweet — rye and sweet vermouth meet Cynar's savoury artichoke bite in place of the usual bitters. Rye's spice and sweet vermouth's dried-fruit warmth meet Cynar's savoury, artichoke-tinged bitterness for a moodier, more herbal spin on the Manhattan — built for a slow night in rather than a crowd.

Prep Time
1.5 min
Method
Stirred
Glass
Coupe glass
Strength
Spirit-forward

Every recipe on Sipped Right is tested for taste and balance before it's published.

Last updated November 16, 2026

Jump to recipe ↓

About the Little Italy

The Little Italy was created in 2005 by bartender Audrey Saunders at New York's Pegu Club, reportedly dreamed up after a round of Manhattans at the Soho restaurant Raoul's. Saunders swapped the Manhattan's dash of Angostura bitters for a full measure of Cynar, the artichoke-based Italian amaro, giving the drink a savoury, herbal depth and a name that nods to the city's own Little Italy.

The build runs 2 oz rye whiskey to 3/4 oz sweet vermouth to 1/2 oz Cynar — a roughly 4:1.5:1 ratio that keeps rye as the clear backbone while carving out room for Cynar's bitter, artichoke-forward edge in place of some of the vermouth's usual sweetness. It's a direct riff on the Manhattan's classic 2:1 spirit-to-vermouth structure: pull the Cynar back out and bump the vermouth up to 1 oz, and it becomes a Manhattan again.

Little Italy cocktail served in a Coupe glass
Ingredients for a Little Italy: Rye whiskey, Sweet vermouth, Cynar laid out on a home kitchen counter

Ingredients

Servings
1
  • Rye whiskey2 oz
  • Sweet vermouth¾ oz
  • Cynar½ oz
  • Luxardo cherries2, for garnish

Method

  1. Measure and pour the rye whiskey, sweet vermouth and Cynar into the mixing glass.
  2. Add a scoop of ice to the mixing glass.
  3. Stir for 30 seconds.
  4. Strain the cocktail into a chilled coupe glass.
  5. Skewer two Luxardo cherries onto a cocktail pick.
  6. Rest the cherry pick across the rim of the glass.
Stirring the Little Italy into a chilled coupe glass
Close-up of the garnish on a Little Italy, expressed over the glass

Glass & Garnish

Coupe glass, chilled, no ice. Garnish with two Luxardo cherries skewered on a cocktail pick.

Notes

A well-documented 2000s modern classic and a direct amaro swap on the Manhattan: 2 oz rye, ¾ oz sweet vermouth and ½ oz Cynar.

Tools Used

Affiliate links

As an Amazon Associate, Sipped Right earns commission from qualifying purchases made via links on this website, at no extra cost to you.

FAQ

What's the best rye whiskey for a Little Italy?
Rittenhouse Rye is the bottle most associated with the original recipe, prized for its high-corn sweetness and assertive, leathery backbone that stands up to Cynar's bitterness. Any solid 100-proof rye works well; a lower-proof or bourbon substitute will soften the drink and mute some of its characteristic spice.
Can I substitute the Cynar in a Little Italy?
Fernet-Branca or Amaro Nonino both make reasonable substitutes, though each shifts the drink's character — Fernet turns it more minty and medicinal, Nonino makes it sweeter and more golden. True Cynar's artichoke-driven bitterness is what defines the standard recipe, so treat substitutes as genuine variations rather than exact matches.
Are there variations on the Little Italy?
Yes — some bartenders swap in Fernet-Branca or another amaro for Cynar, and a few versions add a dash of orange bitters for extra lift. The core 2:3/4:1/2 rye-vermouth-Cynar structure stays constant across most riffs, since it's what keeps the drink recognizably Manhattan-shaped.
What's the traditional garnish for a Little Italy?
Two Luxardo maraschino cherries, skewered on a cocktail pick and rested across the rim. The cherries echo the Manhattan's classic garnish and add a touch of sweetness that balances Cynar's bitter, artichoke-forward edge — skip them and the drink loses some of that intended contrast.
Can I batch a Little Italy for a party?
Yes — multiply the 2:3/4:1/2 rye-vermouth-Cynar ratio by your guest count and mix the batch ahead without ice. Store it in the fridge or at room temperature, then stir individual servings over ice and strain to order, since batching before dilution keeps every glass consistent.

Related Cocktails