Sipped Right iconSippedRight

Whiskey · Classic · Bittersweet

Black Manhattan Recipe

The Manhattan's darker cousin — a rich amaro standing in for sweet vermouth. Rye whiskey's spice meets a rich, bittersweet amaro instead of the Manhattan's usual sweet vermouth — darker, more complex, and a little more bracing than the original.

Prep Time
1.5 min
Method
Stirred
Glass
Coupe glass
Strength
Spirit-forward

Every recipe on Sipped Right is tested for taste and balance before it's published.

Last updated November 16, 2026

Jump to recipe ↓

About the Black Manhattan

The Black Manhattan was created in 2005 by bartender Todd Smith at San Francisco's Bourbon & Branch, swapping the Manhattan's sweet vermouth for a rich Italian amaro. It keeps the Manhattan's exact 2:1 structure, just trading vermouth's lighter sweetness for an amaro's deeper, more bittersweet complexity.

The build keeps the Manhattan's classic 2:1 spirit-to-modifier ratio exactly — 2 oz rye to 1 oz amaro — so the structure stays identical and only the modifier's character changes. Swap the amaro back for sweet vermouth and it's a Manhattan again; the specific amaro used shifts the exact flavour but not the drink's basic identity.

Black Manhattan cocktail served in a Coupe glass with cocktail cherry
Ingredients for a Black Manhattan: Rye whiskey, Amaro Nonino, Angostura Aromatic Bitters laid out on a home kitchen counter

Ingredients

Servings
1
  • Rye whiskey2 oz
  • Amaro Nonino1 oz
  • Angostura Aromatic Bitters2 dashes
  • Cocktail cherry, for garnish1

Method

  1. Measure and pour the rye whiskey, Amaro Nonino and Angostura bitters into the mixing glass.
  2. Add a scoop of ice to the mixing glass.
  3. Stir for 30 seconds.
  4. Strain the cocktail into a chilled coupe.
  5. Garnish with a cocktail cherry.
Stirring the Black Manhattan into a chilled coupe glass
Close-up of the cocktail cherry on a Black Manhattan, expressed over the glass

Glass & Garnish

Coupe glass, chilled. Garnish with a cocktail cherry.

Notes

The Manhattan's 2:1 structure with amaro in place of sweet vermouth. Amaro Nonino is used here; the most commonly cited original uses Amaro Averna.

Tools Used

Affiliate links

As an Amazon Associate, Sipped Right earns commission from qualifying purchases made via links on this website, at no extra cost to you.

FAQ

What's the best whiskey for a Black Manhattan?
A rye whiskey is classic, since its spice cuts through the amaro's richness — bourbon works too for a sweeter, softer result, similar to choosing between the two for a standard Manhattan.
What amaro should I use in a Black Manhattan?
Amaro Averna is the most commonly cited original, prized for its dark caramel sweetness. Amaro Nonino is a well-documented alternative with a lighter, honeyed profile — either works, since the drink's identity comes from using any rich amaro in place of vermouth.
Does a Black Manhattan need a cherry?
Yes — a cocktail cherry is the traditional finish, matching the Manhattan family's standard garnish and adding a touch of sweetness against the amaro's bitterness.
What's the difference between a Black Manhattan and a regular Manhattan?
They share the identical 2:1 whiskey-to-modifier structure — a Manhattan uses sweet vermouth, while a Black Manhattan swaps in a rich amaro for a darker, more bittersweet result.
Who invented the Black Manhattan?
Bartender Todd Smith created it in 2005 at San Francisco's Bourbon & Branch, swapping the Manhattan's sweet vermouth for Amaro Averna while keeping the same 2:1 ratio.
How do I scale a Black Manhattan up for a party?
Use the servings control above to scale the whiskey, amaro, and bitters evenly, then batch everything into a bottle ahead of time — no ice until you're ready to stir and pour.

Related Cocktails