Sipped Right iconSippedRight

Brandy/Cognac · Classic · Sour

Between the Sheets Recipe

Three spirits, one lemon, zero apologies — this is the sour for people who think Sidecars play it too safe. Bright citrus and orange liqueur ride over a warm base of rum and Cognac, giving this sour a rounder, more layered sweetness than most citrus-forward drinks. It's a late-evening sipper for guests who want a classic with real backbone.

Prep Time
2 min
Method
Shaken
Glass
Coupe glass
Strength
Balanced

Every recipe on Sipped Right is tested for taste and balance before it's published.

Last updated November 16, 2026

Jump to recipe ↓

About the Between the Sheets

Between the Sheets is a Prohibition-era cocktail that first appeared in print in Harry McElhone's 1930 book "Barflies and Cocktails," credited to Harry's New York Bar in Paris. Blending white rum, Cognac, and triple sec with lemon juice, it belongs to the same brandy-and-orange-liqueur sour family as the Sidecar, likely developed as a boozier riff on that earlier classic.

The recipe is built on equal parts white rum, Cognac, and triple sec (1 oz each) against a shorter 0.75 oz pour of lemon juice — a fuller, more sour-forward ratio than some versions use — that keeps the drink spirit-forward while the lemon supplies enough acidity to balance the sugar in the triple sec. That equal-parts structure places it squarely in the Sidecar/Corpse Reviver family of brandy sours, though the added rum makes it noticeably boozier than a classic Sidecar.

Between the Sheets cocktail served in a Coupe glass with lemon twist
Ingredients for a Between the Sheets: White rum, Cognac, Triple sec laid out on a home kitchen counter

Ingredients

Servings
1
  • White rum1 oz
  • Cognac1 oz
  • Triple sec1 oz
  • Fresh lemon juice¾ oz
  • Lemon twist, for garnish1 twist

Method

  1. Juice the lemons.
  2. Measure and pour the white rum, Cognac, triple sec and fresh lemon juice into the shaker tin.
  3. Add a scoop of ice to the shaker tin.
  4. Shake for 15 seconds.
  5. Double-strain the cocktail into a chilled coupe glass.
  6. Cut a swath of lemon peel.
  7. Express the peel over the drink and drop it in.
Shaking the Between the Sheets into a chilled coupe glass
Close-up of the lemon twist on a Between the Sheets, expressed over the glass

Glass & Garnish

Coupe glass, chilled. Garnish with a lemon twist.

Notes

Equal parts white rum, Cognac and triple sec, with 20 ml (about ⅔ oz) of lemon juice. The fuller lemon measure keeps the drink sour-forward rather than sweet.

Tools Used

Affiliate links

As an Amazon Associate, Sipped Right earns commission from qualifying purchases made via links on this website, at no extra cost to you.

FAQ

Can I batch Between the Sheets for a party?
Yes — multiply the rum, Cognac, triple sec, and lemon juice by your guest count and combine in a pitcher, but keep the lemon juice separate until just before serving so it stays fresh. Shake individual servings with ice rather than pre-mixing the whole batch shaken, since resting dilutes and dulls the citrus.
What can I use instead of triple sec?
Cointreau or another good-quality orange curaçao both work well and slightly upgrade the drink's citrus-orange character. Avoid swapping in a sweeter orange liqueur without adjusting the lemon juice, since the recipe's balance depends on triple sec's drier, more citrus-forward profile rather than a syrupy orange flavor.
Does the rum or Cognac matter more?
Both do — use a light, mixable white rum (not a heavily spiced or aged one) and a solid VS or VSOP Cognac, since either spirit's flavor is easy to taste through the shake. A rough or overly sweet brandy will throw off the drink's balance faster than a mediocre rum will.
Is there a well-known variation on this cocktail?
The main variation drops the rum entirely, which effectively turns the drink into a Sidecar. Some modern bars also shift the ratio toward more lemon juice for a tarter or more spirit-forward pour.
Does Between the Sheets need a garnish?
Not strictly — it's traditionally served without one, but a lemon twist is the standard real-world addition. Express the oils over the drink before dropping the peel in; it adds aromatic citrus lift without changing the flavor of the cocktail itself.

Related Cocktails