Who invented Hot Buttered Rum?

No single inventor is documented. It traces to Colonial New England in the 1600s, meeting a European tradition of hot buttered drinks dating to the 1500s.

What's the best rum for Hot Buttered Rum?

An aged, darker Caribbean rum works best — its char and vanilla notes hold up against the butter and spice.

Can I make Hot Buttered Rum in a batch for a party?

Yes — most modern recipes use a make-ahead spiced butter batter so guests can stir a spoonful into their own hot rum and water.

Can I make Hot Buttered Rum without butter?

Not really without losing the drink's point — the butter is the defining texture. Omitting it turns this into a simple hot rum toddy instead.

Rum · Classic · Spicy

Hot Buttered Rum Recipe

Aged rum stirred with honey, butter, and nutmeg into hot water. Warm, buttery, and lightly spiced — aged rum stirred with honey, butter, and nutmeg into hot water. A Colonial-era classic built for the coldest night you've got.

Prep Time: 2.5 min
Method: Stirred
Glass: Warmed Irish coffee glass
Strength: Light

Every recipe on Sipped Right is tested for taste and balance before it's published.

Last updated October 20, 2026

Jump to recipe ↓

About the Hot Buttered Rum

Hot Buttered Rum traces to Colonial New England in the 1600s, when rum from Caribbean molasses became the region's dominant spirit and colonists began stirring it into the hot buttered drinks Europeans already favored for cold weather — a tradition itself dating to 1500s England. Jerry Thomas's 1887 Bartender's Guide gives some of the earliest written recipes, largely the same formula used today.

The drink's identity comes from the honey-and-butter base dissolving into hot water before the rum goes in — get that right and it stays silky rather than oily-topped. Most modern recipes use a make-ahead batter for batch serving; this version keeps it single-serve and stirred fresh.

Hot Buttered Rum cocktail served in a Warmed Irish coffee glass

Ingredients

Servings

Honey2 barspoons
Unsalted butter1 knob (~15g)
Aged Caribbean rum2 oz
Fresh nutmeg2 pinches
Hot waterto top
Whipped cream1 dollop, for garnish
Cinnamon stick1, for garnish
Lemon slice studded with cloves1, for garnish

Method

Measure the honey and butter into a warmed Irish coffee glass.
Measure and pour the rum into the glass.
Grate the nutmeg over the top.
Top with hot water.
Stir for 30 seconds, until the honey and butter fully dissolve.
Cut a lemon slice and stud it with cloves.
Spoon a dollop of whipped cream on top.
Place the cinnamon stick and clove-studded lemon slice.

Stirring the Hot Buttered Rum into a chilled warmed irish coffee glass

Close-up of the garnish on a Hot Buttered Rum, expressed over the glass

Glass & Garnish

Warmed Irish coffee glass, garnished with whipped cream, a cinnamon stick and a clove-studded lemon slice.

Notes

For a party, most recipes swap to a make-ahead spiced butter batter (softened butter, brown sugar, and spices creamed together and chilled) so guests can stir their own — this single-serve version suits making one at a time better. Aged Caribbean rum is specified for its char and vanilla notes; a light rum tastes thinner. Common mistake: adding the rum before the honey and butter fully dissolve. Good alongside anything roasted or gingerbread-spiced.

Tools Used

Affiliate links

Jigger Bar spoon

As an Amazon Associate, Sipped Right earns commission from qualifying purchases made via links on this website, at no extra cost to you.

FAQ

Who invented Hot Buttered Rum?: No single inventor is documented. It traces to Colonial New England in the 1600s, meeting a European tradition of hot buttered drinks dating to the 1500s.
What's the best rum for Hot Buttered Rum?: An aged, darker Caribbean rum works best — its char and vanilla notes hold up against the butter and spice.
Can I make Hot Buttered Rum in a batch for a party?: Yes — most modern recipes use a make-ahead spiced butter batter so guests can stir a spoonful into their own hot rum and water.
Can I make Hot Buttered Rum without butter?: Not really without losing the drink's point — the butter is the defining texture. Omitting it turns this into a simple hot rum toddy instead.