Rum · Tiki & Tropicals · Creamy
Bushwacker Recipe
A blended rum-and-chocolate milkshake, born on a Virgin Islands bar and adopted by Pensacola beaches. Creamy and genuinely boozy rather than dessert-sweet, with coffee and chocolate notes layered over coconut — built for a hot afternoon, not a nightcap.
- Prep Time
- 2 min
- Method
- Blended
- Glass
- Hurricane glass
- Strength
- Balanced
Every recipe on Sipped Right is tested for taste and balance before it's published.
Last updated October 20, 2026
About the Bushwacker
The Bushwacker is a frozen, blended cocktail of dark rum, coffee liqueur, dark crème de cacao, cream of coconut and half-and-half — essentially a boozy chocolate piña colada. It was created in 1975 at the Ship's Store bar in Sapphire Village, St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands, then carried to Pensacola Beach, Florida, where it became the signature drink of the Sandshaker Lounge and the Flora-Bama. Sandshaker owner Linda Taylor Murphy is widely credited with bringing the recipe home from the islands and tailoring it for her bar, and Flora-Bama co-owner Pat McClellan built his own version soon after — the two roadhouses have traded bragging rights over the "real" Bushwacker ever since. The Flora-Bama, which straddles the Florida–Alabama state line, still markets itself as the "Home of the Bushwacker" and keeps its exact recipe a closely guarded secret; Pensacola has informally claimed the drink as its own for decades.
The base recipe runs equal parts dark rum, coffee liqueur and dark crème de cacao against a double measure each of cream of coconut and half-and-half — a 1:1:1:2:2 ratio that keeps the drink genuinely boozy (three full ounces of spirit and liqueur) rather than sliding into dessert territory. It's effectively a spiked, chocolate-flecked Piña Colada: drop the crème de cacao and coffee liqueur and dial up the coconut, and you're back at that simpler classic.
Ingredients
- Dark rum1 oz
- Coffee liqueur1 oz
- Dark crème de cacao1 oz
- Cream of coconut2 oz
- Half-and-half2 oz
- Crushed ice, for blending1 cup
- Maraschino cherry, for garnish1
- Freshly grated nutmeg, for garnishPinch
Method
- Measure and pour the dark rum, coffee liqueur, dark crème de cacao, cream of coconut and half-and-half into the blender.
- Add a scoop of crushed ice to the blender.
- Blend for 15 seconds.
- Pour the cocktail into a hurricane glass.
- Drop a maraschino cherry on top.
- Grate fresh nutmeg over the drink.
Glass & Garnish
Hurricane glass, poured straight from the blender with no additional ice — the drink is already frozen and slushy from blending crushed ice directly into the mix, so it holds its thick, cold, milkshake texture without watering down further. The tall, curved hurricane shape is the traditional vessel for blended tropical drinks and gives the thick pour enough headroom without looking skimpy. Garnish with a maraschino cherry on top and a light grating of fresh nutmeg over the surface. The cherry is a straightforward visual finish, but the nutmeg does real work — its warm spice plays off the coffee liqueur and crème de cacao the same way it does on a classic eggnog or Painkiller, cutting the sweetness before you taste it.
Notes
Bar-to-bar recipes vary widely — Sandshaker, Flora-Bama and LuLu's each guard a house ratio, so light rum or whole milk in place of half-and-half are both well within tradition. Scales and batches easily; blend the base with ice fresh per serving rather than pre-blending far ahead, since it separates once melted.
Tools Used
Affiliate links
As an Amazon Associate, Sipped Right earns commission from qualifying purchases made via links on this website, at no extra cost to you.
FAQ
- Where did the Bushwacker cocktail come from?
- It was created in 1975 at the Ship's Store bar in Sapphire Village, St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands, then brought to Pensacola Beach's Sandshaker Lounge and later the Flora-Bama, both of which still claim it as their signature drink today.
- What kind of rum should I use in a Bushwacker?
- A standard dark or amber rum — Bacardi Black or similar — gives the traditional Bushwacker its color and mild caramel note without overpowering the coffee and chocolate. Light rum works too and is common in the original Virgin Islands version, with a slightly cleaner finish.
- Can I use whole milk instead of half-and-half in a Bushwacker?
- Yes — whole milk makes a slightly lighter, less rich drink, while half-and-half or light cream gives the classic Gulf Coast thickness. Some bars go further and blend in a scoop of vanilla ice cream for an even creamier, milkshake-style pour.
- Is a Bushwacker the same as a Painkiller or a Piña Colada?
- No — a Piña Colada has no coffee or chocolate, and a Painkiller swaps the dairy and cacao for pineapple and orange juice with a nutmeg dusting. The Bushwacker is closer to a spiked chocolate milkshake, built specifically around coffee liqueur and dark crème de cacao.
- Why is nutmeg grated over a Bushwacker?
- Nutmeg's warm spice cuts through the coffee liqueur and crème de cacao's sweetness before the first sip, the same trick used on eggnog and the Painkiller. A maraschino cherry on top is the other standard finish, and most bars use both.
- Can I make a big batch of Bushwackers ahead of a party?
- Yes — measure and mix the rum, coffee liqueur, crème de cacao, cream of coconut and half-and-half in a pitcher ahead of time, but hold off on the ice. Blend each round fresh with ice right before serving so the texture stays thick and frosty instead of separating.
