Aperitif/Liqueur · Modern Classic · Creamy
Nutty Irishman Recipe
Two nutty, creamy liqueurs, one equal-parts pour, and a rocks glass -- the Nutty Irishman is dessert you can stir together in seconds. A dessert disguised as a cocktail, the Nutty Irishman pairs the cocoa-vanilla warmth of Irish cream with the toasted-almond sweetness of amaretto for an easy, indulgent after-dinner sipper. Built over ice and gently stirred, it's less a mixed drink than liquid dessert in a glass.
- Prep Time
- 0.5 min
- Method
- Stirred
- Glass
- Rocks glass
- Strength
- Balanced
Every recipe on Sipped Right is tested for taste and balance before it's published.
Last updated November 16, 2026
About the Nutty Irishman
The Nutty Irishman emerged from the 1970s-80s wave of Irish-cream shooters that followed Baileys' 1974 debut, when bartenders began pairing its chocolate-vanilla body with nutty liqueurs like Frangelico. Documented history is thin -- it's a bar-menu staple, rather than a codified classic -- but the pairing endured, evolving from a quick layered shot into this sippable, built-over-ice version.
Built at a roughly equal 1.5oz:1.5oz split, the Nutty Irishman lets its two liqueurs share the stage: Irish cream's cocoa-vanilla creaminess against amaretto's toasted-almond sweetness. Neither ingredient dominates, which is what defines the drink's balance -- much like other twin-liqueur sippers such as the Godfather (Scotch and amaretto), where equal parts is the standard that keeps the drink from tipping too sweet or too heavy.


Ingredients
- Irish cream liqueur1 ½ oz
- Amaretto1 ½ oz
Method
- Fill a rocks glass with ice.
- Measure and pour the Irish cream liqueur and amaretto over the ice.
- Stir gently in the glass for 5 seconds.


Glass & Garnish
Rocks glass, over ice. No garnish.
Notes
Just two ingredients — Irish cream and amaretto in equal parts. Traditional three-ingredient versions add Irish whiskey and Frangelico (sometimes called an Irish Godfather); amaretto is a documented substitute for the hazelnut liqueur.
Tools Used
Affiliate links
As an Amazon Associate, Sipped Right earns commission from qualifying purchases made via links on this website, at no extra cost to you.
FAQ
- Why doesn't the Nutty Irishman contain whiskey?
- Despite the 'Irishman' in its name, this version skips whiskey entirely -- it's built from two liqueurs, Irish cream and amaretto, whose combined nutty, creamy character is the whole point. The name nods to Irish cream's Irish heritage, not to a whiskey base.
- Can I use Frangelico instead of amaretto?
- Yes -- Frangelico (hazelnut liqueur) is actually the more traditional partner for Irish cream in this drink. Amaretto is a widely available, well-documented substitute with a similar toasted-nut sweetness, which is what this recipe uses.
- What glass and garnish does the Nutty Irishman use?
- It's served in a rocks glass over ice, gently stirred, with no garnish needed -- the drink's opaque, creamy color is the visual, though a light dusting of cocoa or nutmeg is a common optional finish.
- How strong is a Nutty Irishman?
- Both Irish cream and amaretto sit around 17-20% ABV, and there's no base spirit, so this is a light, easy-sipping drink rather than a strong one -- perfect for a slow, after-dinner pace.
Related Cocktails

Aperitif/Liqueur
Snowball
Britain's favourite guilty-pleasure Christmas cocktail — creamy advocaat and fizzy lemonade in one nostalgic, unapologetically sweet glass.

Vodka
Mudslide
Equal parts vodka, coffee liqueur and Irish cream — a dessert disguised as a cocktail.

Vodka
White Russian
Vodka, coffee liqueur and cream, built over ice — dessert in a glass.

Whiskey
Irish Coffee
Hot coffee and Irish whiskey topped with cream — a nightcap and a pick-me-up in one glass.
